Best Real Estate Agents in Indiana — 2026 Rankings
We ranked 46 real estate agents across 1 cities in Indiana.
-
#1 — Chelsea Noble Realty Score: 29/100
Indianapolis, IN — Chelsea Noble - Real Estate Agent in Carmel, IN
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#2 — Seniors Real Estate Experts Score: 29/100
Indianapolis, IN — Seniors Real Estate Experts is an established real estate agent based in Indianapolis, IN. Reach them at +13177312289 or email hello@downsizingindy.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 9465 Counselors Row.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#3 — Collin Tingle, Realtor Score: 28/100
New Albany, IN — Homes for Sale in Southern Indiana : Search the SIRA MLS : collintingle.SchulerBauer.com
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#4 — Amy Quinn-Yeker Score: 27/100
New Albany, IN — Serving New Albany and the surrounding IN region, Amy Quinn-Yeker is available at +15027278807. Visit their website for more information on their real estate services.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#5 — Browning Score: 27/100
Indianapolis, IN —
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#6 — Janelle Keele Real Estate Score: 27/100
Indianapolis, IN — Janelle Keele, REALTOR®, Real Estate Agent
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#7 — 92c Partners Score: 27/100
Indianapolis, IN —
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#8 — Matlock Realty Group Score: 26/100
Indianapolis, IN — Real Estate in Indianapolis, IN
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#9 — Centurion Land Title Score: 26/100
Indianapolis, IN — Centurion Land Title is a real estate agent serving Indianapolis, IN. Contact them at +13176638091 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#10 — JPAR Aspire Real Estate Score: 25/100
New Albany, IN — JPAR Aspire Real Estate has been providing real estate services to the New Albany community since 2001. Reach them at +18127257878 or email jparaspire@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1709 McDonald Ln.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#11 — Mera Realty Group Score: 25/100
Indianapolis, IN —
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#12 — Jenna Skipper - Realtor Score: 25/100
Jeffersonville, IN —
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#13 — Elite Realty Pros Score: 24/100
Indianapolis, IN — Elite Realty Pros brings reliable real estate services to Indianapolis and nearby communities in IN. Reach out at +13177105019 or visit them online.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#14 — Sales Pop Score: 23/100
Indianapolis, IN —
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#15 — Melanie Murphy Homes Score: 22/100
New Albany, IN — Melanie Murphy Homes is a real estate agent serving New Albany, IN. Contact them at +15028108105 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#16 — ZZONE 31 Score: 22/100
Indianapolis, IN — ZZONE 31 is a real estate agent serving Indianapolis, IN. Contact them at +13174290060 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#17 — Barron Property Services Score: 22/100
Indianapolis, IN — Barron Property Services
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#18 — Ala Carte Realty Score: 22/100
Indianapolis, IN — Ala Carte Realty Making Homeownership Possible
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#19 — Tiffani Leffel Score: 20/100
Indianapolis, IN — Tiffani Leffel is an Indianapolis-based real estate agent offering comprehensive services to clients across IN. Reach them at +13176982292 or email tiffanileffel@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 711 E 65th St.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#20 — Johnny Wright Score: 20/100
Indianapolis, IN —
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
How We Rank Real Estate Agents
The Directory information score is a 0–100 summary of captured profile and public review information. Fixed point limits apply to public ratings, review volume, web presence, profile completeness, listed credentials, press mentions, and reported experience. Missing information contributes no points. A low score may reflect missing data; the score does not measure service quality or guarantee suitability. Read our full methodology →