Best Real Estate Agents in Indiana — 2026 Rankings
We ranked 49 real estate agents across 1 cities in Indiana.
-
#1 — Chelsea Noble Realty Score: 29/100
Indianapolis, IN — Chelsea Noble - Real Estate Agent in Carmel, IN
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#2 — The Ardizzone Group Score: 29/100
Beech Grove, IN — The Ardizzone Group
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#3 — Lesa Furman, Indys Real Estate Pros Score: 24/100
Indianapolis, IN — Indianapolis IN Real Estate
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#4 — Johnny Wright Score: 23/100
Indianapolis, IN — For real estate in Indianapolis, IN, Johnny Wright stands out as a reliable choice. Reach them at +13179463426 or email johnnyw@talktotucker.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 3405 E 86th St.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#5 — Call Vandersall Score: 23/100
Indianapolis, IN — Call Vandersall provides real estate services across Indianapolis, IN. Reach them at +13173456643 or email john.vandersall@talktotucker.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 3405 E 86th St.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#6 — Zuniga Property Group Score: 23/100
Indianapolis, IN — A real estate agent in the heart of Indianapolis, Zuniga Property Group is just a phone call away at +13176524401. Learn more on their website.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#7 — Julie Blackman, Schuler Bauer Real Estate Agent Score: 23/100
New Albany, IN — Serving homeowners and businesses in New Albany, Julie Blackman, Schuler Bauer Real Estate Agent is a dependable real estate agent in IN. Reach them at +15025230672 or email julieblackman@schulerbauer.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#8 — Chris Buys Homes in Indianapolis Score: 23/100
Indianapolis, IN — Chris Buys Homes in Indianapolis is a trusted name in real estate in Indianapolis, IN. Reach them at +13175264712 or email info@chrisbuyshomesindy.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1151 Standish Ave.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#9 — Statewide Realty LLC Score: 23/100
Evansville, IN — Statewide Realty LLC is a real estate agent proudly serving Evansville, IN. Reach them at +18124344663. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 400 N St Joseph Ave. Reach them at +18124344663. Visit their website to learn more about their work.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#10 — Pam Webb Score: 23/100
Indianapolis, IN — Pam Webb brings professional real estate expertise to the Indianapolis, IN community. Reach them at +13174501376 or email p.j.webb@sbcglobal.net. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 8710 Bash St.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#11 — Realtor Ravi Score: 22/100
Fishers, IN — The Kelly Dather Real Estate Group | KW Indy Metro Northeast
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#12 — Harp Realty Indianapolis Score: 22/100
Indianapolis, IN — As a real estate agent in Indianapolis, Harp Realty Indianapolis works with clients across the IN region. Reach them at +13175788202 or email info@harpagent.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 9465 Counselors Row.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#13 — Leigh Ann Harrison, Realtor, Evelo Team, Keller Williams Realty Score: 22/100
Fishers, IN — Looking for a real estate agent in Fishers? Leigh Ann Harrison, Realtor, Evelo Team, Keller Williams Realty serves the greater Fishers metropolitan area. Call +13178639011 or visit their site for details. What clients say: "We love the Evelo Team.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#14 — Crissi Matthews, REALTOR Score: 22/100
Indianapolis, IN — Need a real estate agent in Indianapolis? Crissi Matthews, REALTOR is ready to help with your next project. Reach them at 3179093111. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1300 E 86th St Unit 40998. Reach them at 3179093111.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#15 — Shine Realty Score: 20/100
Indianapolis, IN — Shine Realty — Real Estate in Indianapolis, IN
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#16 — Tiffani Leffel Score: 20/100
Indianapolis, IN — Tiffani Leffel is an Indianapolis-based real estate agent offering comprehensive services to clients across IN. Reach them at +13176982292 or email tiffanileffel@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 711 E 65th St.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#17 — Claysburg Two Towers Score: 20/100
Jeffersonville, IN — Claysburg Two Towers is a Jeffersonville-based real estate agent offering comprehensive services to clients across IN. Reach them at +18122833762 or email lowincomesupport@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1306 Wall St.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#18 — Mary Bryant - Real Estate Score: 20/100
Indianapolis, IN — Mary Bryant - Real Estate is a leading real estate agent in Indianapolis, IN. Reach them at +13178219489 or email mary@indyhomepros.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 2611 Waterfront Parkway East Dr.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#19 — Jason Eddy & Co Score: 20/100
Evansville, IN — Jason Eddy & Co has built a reputation for quality real estate work in the Evansville, IN area. Services include professional services. Located at 130 Main St. Reach them at +18124994519. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#20 — The Algonquin Building Score: 20/100
Indianapolis, IN — The Algonquin Building is a real estate agent based in Indianapolis, IN, dedicated to delivering quality real estate services. Services include real estate service, professional services. Located at 225 N Delaware St. Reach them at +13172691999.
Services: General. View full profile →
How We Rank Real Estate Agents
Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CRS/ABR/SRES (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). Read our full methodology →