Best Real Estate Agents in Evansville, IN — 2026 Rankings
We ranked 32 real estate agents in Evansville based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and experience.
Top Real Estate Agents in Evansville
-
#1 — Helfrich Realty Co Inc Score: 29/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#2 — Stephanie Morris, Realtor Score: 24/100
Stephanie Morris, Realtor is a real estate agent serving the Evansville, IN community. Reach them at +18124849030 or email stephaniemorris@fctuckeremge.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 130 Main St.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#3 — Gammon Realty Score: 24/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#4 — Comfort Homes Score: 22/100
Comfort Homes is a leading real estate agent in Evansville, IN. Reach them at 8124735555. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 2400 E Morgan Ave. Reach them at 8124735555. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 2400 E Morgan Ave.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#5 — Deli Muz Score: 21/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#6 — Goebel Realty Score: 20/100
Goebel Realty, a real estate agent in Evansville, IN, focuses on quality and client satisfaction. Reach them at +18124229054 or email info@goebelrealty.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1011 W Franklin St.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#7 — Flipping Evansville Score: 20/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#8 — Southwestern Indiana Land Title Score: 20/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#9 — Jill Sold Mine Score: 20/100
Serving Evansville and the surrounding IN region, Jill Sold Mine is available at +18123054170. Visit their website for more information on their real estate services.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#10 — SVN | The Martin Group Score: 20/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#11 — Arbors Score: 19/100
For professional real estate services in Evansville, IN, contact Arbors at +18124240790 or explore their website.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#12 — ERA First Advantage Realty Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#13 — Tristatehomefinder Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#14 — EvansvilleHomesForRent.com Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#15 — Catanese Real Estate Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#16 — Sara Wibberley Score: 17/100
For professional real estate services in Evansville, IN, contact Sara Wibberley at +18122000404 or explore their website.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#17 — Donita Wolf Score: 17/100
Based in Evansville, Donita Wolf provides quality real estate services to the greater IN area. Reach them at +18122049255 or email donitawolf@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 2221 W Franklin St.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#18 — John M. Caldwell Homes Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#19 — Evansville Student Housing Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#20 — Landmark Realty & Development Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#21 — Brantley Realty Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#22 — Jennifer Stallings - Extreme RE Real Estate Score: 17/100
A real estate agent in the heart of Evansville, Jennifer Stallings - Extreme RE Real Estate is just a phone call away at +18124701708. Learn more on their website.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#23 — Brash Properties Evansville Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#24 — Evansville Historic Homes Score: 17/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#25 — Donnie Dowell Score: 17/100
Residents of Evansville, IN looking for expert real estate services can rely on Donnie Dowell. Reach them at +18124498026 or email donnie@atpropertiesind.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 3116 E Morgan Ave.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#26 — Cathy Baron, ERA First Advantage Realty Score: 17/100
Cathy Baron, ERA First Advantage Realty is a real estate agent proudly serving Evansville, IN. Reach them at +18124618400 or email cathy.baron@erafirst.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 2221 W Franklin St.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#27 — Hometown Title Score: 17/100
Hometown Title delivers personalized real estate solutions to clients throughout Evansville, IN. Reach them at +18124616399 or email orders@hometowntitles.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 25 NW Riverside Dr.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#28 — Flaherty and Collins Propertie Score: 13/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#29 — Evansville Homes Score: 13/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#30 — Legacy Commons Apartments Score: 12/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#31 — Bryan Properties Score: 8/100
You can find Bryan Properties, a real estate agent serving Evansville, IN, at 2305 S Rotherwood Ave. Stop by or call to learn more.
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
-
#32 — David Matthews Associates Score: 8/100
Services: Services not recorded. View full profile →
How We Rank Real Estate Agents
The Directory information score is a 0–100 summary of captured profile and public review information. Fixed point limits apply to public ratings, review volume, web presence, profile completeness, listed credentials, press mentions, and reported experience. Missing information contributes no points. A low score may reflect missing data; the score does not measure service quality or guarantee suitability. Read our full methodology →
Frequently asked questions
- Which real estate agent has the highest information score on this results page in Evansville?
- Helfrich Realty Co Inc has the highest Directory information score among the listings shown on this page. The score summarizes recorded profile information; it does not establish service quality or suitability.
- How are real estate agents ranked in Evansville?
- The Directory information score is a 0–100 summary of captured profile and public review information. Fixed point limits apply to public ratings, review volume, web presence, profile completeness, listed credentials, press mentions, and reported experience. Missing information contributes no points. A low score may reflect missing data; the score does not measure service quality or guarantee suitability. There is no paid placement.
- What real estate services are most common in Evansville?
- Evansville's represented services will populate as we verify more agents.