Best Real Estate Agents in New Albany, OH (2026)
Choosing the right real estate agent in New Albany, OH can be overwhelming. Our directory contains 68 active real estate agents records for the New Albany area. Use the available information to build a shortlist and verify fit directly. At The Realtor Rankings, we analyze publicly available data to order the listed profiles using the stated comparison method -- no paid placements, no sponsored rankings.
This 2026 ranking evaluates real estate agents in New Albany, Ohio using our Directory information score, which adds fixed points for captured public reviews, listed credentials, press mentions, web presence, reported experience, and profile completeness. The directory contains 68 active business records in this market; 15 appear in this list.
By the numbers: Directory information scores on this list range from 17/100 to 29/100, 1 of 15 profiles list credentials, the average age based on recorded founding years is 28 years. Source coverage varies between profiles.
Each entry below includes the business's Directory information score, star rating, review count, and an explanation of the recorded information used in the comparison. Click through to any profile for the full breakdown including contact information, specialties, credentials, and related businesses in New Albany.
The Top 15 Real Estate Agents in New Albany, OH
-
Selected for 28 years of experience (est. 1998).
Thomas|Riddle Real Estate Group - New Albany Realty is a New Albany, OH real estate agent ready to help with your next project. Call 6149391234 or check out their website.
View full profile → -
#2 Brandon Hartley, NMLS 173898 24/100
Ranked 2nd among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
Serving New Albany and the surrounding OH region, Brandon Hartley, NMLS 173898 is available at +16142090876. Visit their website for more information on their real estate services.
View full profile → -
Selected for Realtor certified.
Julie R. Wills | Julie & Company | Howard Hanna Real Estate Services brings professional real estate expertise to the New Albany, OH community. Welcome to the best online resource for all of your Cen…
View full profile → -
#4 Old Republic Title 18/100
Selected for specializes in your solution for commercial transactions, proudly serving our policy issuing agents, our full suite of services supports success:.
Old Republic Title brings reliable real estate services to New Albany and nearby communities in OH. Reach out at 6143411900 or visit them online.
View full profile → -
#5 Kimarie Martin Realtor 18/100
Selected for specializes in search search, featured listings, country club communities.
Kimarie Martin Realtor provides real estate services across New Albany, OH. Reach them at +16142141618 or email kimarie@therainesgroup.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located…
View full profile → -
#6 Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group 17/100
Ranked 6th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
Based in New Albany, Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group provides quality real estate services to the greater OH area. Reach them at +16149391234 or email info@thomasriddle.com. Visit their website to le…
View full profile → -
#7 SMRE Brokerage 17/100
Ranked 7th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
From their base in New Albany, SMRE Brokerage serves real estate clients across OH. Reach them at +16144190080 or email master.smrebrokerage@gmail.com. Visit their website to learn more about their w…
View full profile → -
Ranked 8th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
Stacey Lambright, Jim Lambright, The Lambright Team, a real estate agent based in New Albany, OH, welcomes inquiries at +16143154663 and through their website.
View full profile → -
#9 HER Realtors 17/100
Ranked 9th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
Serving New Albany and the surrounding OH region, HER Realtors is available at (614) 855-8700. Visit their website for more information on their real estate services.
View full profile → -
#10 Ashley Oliver KW Greater Columbus 17/100
Ranked 10th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
A real estate agent in the heart of New Albany, Ashley Oliver KW Greater Columbus is just a phone call away at +16149569886. Learn more on their website.
View full profile → -
#11 Cathy Fleischmann, Cutler Real Estate 17/100
Ranked 11th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
A real estate agent in the heart of New Albany, Cathy Fleischmann, Cutler Real Estate is just a phone call away at +16145194081. Learn more on their website.
View full profile → -
#12 David Carroll 17/100
Ranked 12th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
David Carroll provides real estate services in New Albany, OH. Reach them by phone at +16142969610 or online to discuss your project.
View full profile → -
#13 Hometeam Solutions 17/100
Ranked 13th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
View full profile → -
#14 Jennifer Popham, Columbus Home Expert 17/100
Ranked 14th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
Serving homeowners and businesses in New Albany, Jennifer Popham, Columbus Home Expert is a dependable real estate agent in OH. Reach them at +16142048088 or email jennifer@therainesgroup.com. Visit…
View full profile → -
#15 Jim Van Paepeghem, Realtor 17/100
Ranked 15th among real estate agents in this market based on overall Directory information score.
Jim Van Paepeghem, Realtor appears in this directory as a real estate agent serving New Albany, OH. Use the location and contact fields on this page to verify fit before reaching out. Address on file…
View full profile →
How We Ranked These Real Estate Agents
The Directory information score adds fixed points for captured public ratings, review volume, web presence, profile completeness, listed credentials, press mentions, and reported experience, up to 100 points. Missing data contributes no points; a low score may mean missing information. It does not measure service quality. No business can pay for a higher score.
Profile coverage and sources vary. Follow the source attribution and business links on each profile, verify credentials with the issuing organization, and confirm current availability and terms directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did we rank the best real estate agents in New Albany?
The Realtor Rankings orders profiles using the Directory information score, a 0–100 summary of captured profile and public review information. Fixed point limits apply to ratings, review volume, web presence, profile completeness, listed credentials, press mentions, and reported experience. Missing information contributes no points. A low score may mean missing data; the score is not a measure of service quality or a recommendation. There is no paid placement.
Who is the #1 real estate agent in New Albany, OH?
Thomas|Riddle Real Estate Group - New Albany Realty appears first in this Directory information score comparison for New Albany, with a Directory information score of 29/100. This reflects recorded information and the selected sort order, not an independent assessment of service quality.
How often is this list updated?
Lists are generated from the records currently held in the directory. Imports and corrections may change their order. Update timing varies by source; this page does not claim a monthly audit or independent verification of every fact.
How many real estate agents are there in New Albany?
Our database currently tracks 68 active real estate agents in the New Albany, OH metro area. This list highlights the top 15 based on Directory information score. Browse our full New Albany directory to see every listed business.
Can a real estate agent pay to be ranked higher?
No. The Realtor Rankings does not accept payment for rankings. Directory information scores are computed algorithmically from recorded profile information. Businesses can claim and update their profile with accurate information, but the ranking algorithm treats all profiles equally. Our editorial independence is core to our methodology.
What should I look for when hiring a real estate agent in New Albany?
We recommend evaluating: (1) professional certifications and credentials, (2) verified customer reviews and ratings, (3) years of experience in the New Albany market, (4) portfolio quality and range of work, (5) budget alignment with your project scope, and (6) responsiveness and communication style. The Directory information score cannot assess project fit, responsiveness, workmanship, or outcomes; use it alongside these checks.